Prompt: Birthday Boy (Fairy Tail)

Summary: Lucy gives a 'One Free Wish' card to Romeo for his birthday, and he knows what he wants immediately. He wants to fuck her, and Lucy gives him what he wants. Includes: NTR and anal

---

Lucy stood in her bathroom with a question on her mind. It was a simple question that could be summed up in just one sentence. One single statement.

How did she end up here?

Well, the answer to that was as simple as the question, but it didn’t change the fact that Lucy was… amused? Bemused? Stunned by her situation?

It had been Romeo’s birthday recently. The young boy was now a man, and for his birthday, Lucy had given him a card for one free wish. She would do anything for the young man, follow whatever his command could have been. 

At the time, Lucy expected a free meal, or to teach him to fight, or even a kiss. Instead, Romeo went the extra mile and asked, no, demanded sex, promising Lucy he wouldn’t tell a soul as she picked her jaw up off of the floor. 

Lucy was dating Natsu at the time, but she had given her word to fulfill any wish Romeo had for his birthday. It wasn’t like Romeo was a bad person. He was a kind and sweet boy, but he had certainly inherited certain… naughty desires from his friends growing up.

She had given her word, and as a Celestial Mage, how could she betray that? It didn’t hurt that Romeo had grown up into a handsome, strapping young man… Or that Natsu had been ignorant of her needs and desires lately…

Luckily, Lucy had sent him off to his own home, leaving her alone for the rest of the night. Hopefully that would be all she and Romeo would need. 

Lucy took a deep breath and sighed, closing her eyes as she focused herself. This was the right thing to do. She would keep her word, and maybe, have a good time…

---

Romeo waited in Lucy’s bedroom, sitting in a soft, cushioned chair as the seconds ticked by. He heard the bathroom door open, and he looked up, gasping as he saw Lucy walk towards him in nothing but a towel.

The young man was already naked, so Lucy could see what effect her entrance had on him. His dick was hardening, rising up between his legs as she sighed in her head. She put on a smile for him, swaying her hips side to side.

She tapped her finger against her phone, and music began to play, falling into sync with Lucy’s gyrating hips. She glanced at his erection, smiling in approval at the size of it, at least. He rivaled Natsu’s size.

The older woman walked towards Romeo, sitting on the man’s lap and moving her hips back against him. Her ass rubbed against his hard dick as she smiled at him. 

“Ready for the best present of your life?” she whispered, making Romeo beam. He nodded his head, and Lucy gave him a wink, before she began. 

She moved her body on top of him, listening to his awed moans and shudders of pleasure. Her pussy rubbed against his erect cock, and Lucy could feel him throbbing against her slit. She held back a moan, feeling his dick press against her. 

The blond beauty bit her lower lip, silently hoping Natsu would never find out about this. Or about how much she might have been enjoying herself.

As Lucy was lost to her worried thoughts, Romeo looked at the towel wrapped around her body. She looked so good in it. Lucy was ridiculously gorgeous, and even wrapped around as something as a towel left her beauty obvious. 

Her large tits pushed against the towel, and it clearly strained to contain her hourglass figure. Romeo decided to help it out, and he grabbed at the towel, pulling on it as Lucy’s eyes widened. He tore the towel off of her body, revealing her voluptuous figure.

Lucy smiled at the action. She was glad to see he was so bold. She rewarded him, and herself, by continuing to rub her pussy against his body, moaning softly at the heavenly sensation. She turned so that she was facing him, giving her better access to his cock as she placed her hands on her tits.

She played with her tits right before his eyes, and like any man, he loved the sight of Lucy’s tits bouncing and jiggling side to side. The blond was starting to get wet, and her juices began to lube the dick, getting it ready for her.

“You’re so sexy,” he whispered with awe in his voice as her pussy rubbed against his shaft.  

Lucy smiled at the compliment. He certainly knew how to make a girl feel adored. She leaned down to peck his forehead. “Are you ready for the main course?” she teased. He nodded his head vigorously as she giggled.

She lifted her hips up, before she slowly slid his cock into her waiting pussy. Lucy had gotten surprisingly wet from just rubbing against his dick, and his cock seemed to fit just right inside of her as she moaned in pleasure.

Feeling him inside of her now, she realized he was smaller than her boyfriend, but he definitely had something special. A gift. Potential. She moaned as his cock throbbed inside of her, and her body bounced against his.

Lucy moved her hips up and down, panting as the tip of the dick kissed the inside of her womanhood. She started off slow, letting Romeo get a feel for her pussy, only for the young man to grab her hips. 

He tried making her go faster, but Lucy was just a bit stronger than him. She was in control of the rhythm, but she was a kind lover. If Romeo wanted her best, she’d be happy to give it to him. 

Lucy began to move faster, making Romeo moan in pleasure as she even flexed her muscles. Her pussy tightened around his shaft, stroking the sides of his dick with her tight pussy. She admired his moaning, panting face as she leaned closer. 

She kissed his lips, and Romeo kissed back. Much like how he was fucking her, he was messy and inexperienced, but he had a passion to him. His arms wrapped around Lucy, and she moaned into the kiss as his tongue pushed into her mouth, licking her tongue. 

Lucy ended up breaking the kiss. Saliva linked their mouths, but she licked it up as she smiled. “So... Do I feel as good as you’d hope?”

“B-better!” he shouted back, before slapping his hand against her ass. There was a loud clap, and Lucy moaned at the blow, shuddering from the smack.

It made her pussy tighten around his shaft, and he moaned at the warm embrace. He had never imagined it would feel this good. He expected it to be amazing, but this was addicting. He couldn’t imagine going back to masturbating after this, or hell, girls his age.

Lucy was a goddess. She had experienced, and beauty, and natural talent all mixed together. Her wet walls slid along his penis, squeezing him as her tits continued to bounce in his face. He couldn’t control himself, shaking as he spoke.

“I-I’m gonna cum.” Lucy moaned in response, closing her eyes as she had his dick press against her sweet spot. 

Lucy moaned, before suddenly getting off of Romeo. He watched her sink down to her knees before him, and she opened her mouth to welcome his glistening cock into her mouth. Lucy bobbed her head up and down, only reaching about halfway down his shaft before he began to cum.

The blond lifted her head up, right off his dick. Cum shot out of his dick, jets of his seed falling onto her gorgeous face and golden locks… What didn’t hit her hair or face fell down, right onto her tits. Some of the cum on her face even dripped down onto her rack as she smiled. 

“Can you keep going?” she asked, and he told her he could.

Lucy got up and placed a hand on her wall. She spanked her ass, making it jiggle for Romeo as she smiled. “Then come here and fuck me from behind!” she ordered, and Romeo was more than happy to.

He gave her ass a slap, making it jiggle even harder than last time, before he slammed his cock into her cunt. He moaned loudly as her pussy squeezed down on his shaft, clinging to the sides of his penis as he bucked his hips back and forth.

Even as he fucked her, his inexperience was obvious to Lucy. His thrusts were wild, but also awkward. She turned her head, watching him hump her pussy with a chuckle. 

“You need to get into a rhythm if you want to make me cum,” she teased, smirking at him.

“S-sorry,” he replied, panting. He took a deep breath, and shot a smirk back at her. Lucy loved that look in his eyes as he resumed fucking her, pounding her pussy with improved gusto. 

“Ahhh… Yes, that’s it! H-harder…” He obeyed, not only finding his rhythm, but fucking her even faster and harder. Her ass cheeks were jiggling, bouncing as Romeo pounded her pussy. “Ahh… Romeo…” 

The young man gulped. He had never thought he could love the sound of someone saying his name so much, but… Lucy was such a hot woman. She could moan almost anything and it would still come off as erotic. 

He leaned forward, placing a hand on her chest to grope her breast, pinching her nipples between his fingers, before he outright pulled on her nipple. 

She moaned loudly, pumping her hips against him to match his pace as Romeo felt something new dawned on him. Lucy felt his thrusts slow down, before resuming faster than her. He fucked her hard and fast, even as he leaned down to whisper. 

“I wonder what Natsu would think about this…?”

Lucy was impressed at the kinky, somewhat dominant nature Romeo had in bed. Who knew he was such a little sadist? She played along, leaning her head back to whine in protests through her moans.

“N-no! Don’t tell, ahhh! D-don’t tell Natsu, please!” Romeo laughed, clearly proud of himself on actually getting Lucy to play along.

“Wow, Lucy. You have a gift for this,” Lucy teased, before she was sent back to reality. She turned, looking at Romeo with a hungry smile on her face. “You’re so much better than Natsu. More of a man. With such a big cock… Bigger than his!” she teased.

Hearing praise coming from the hottest woman in Fairy Tail was so damn good. He shuddered at just the thought of it, and the reality was even better. Romeo raised up his hand, bringing it down on Lucy’s ass, making her moan quietly. 

“Slut!” he insulted her, and Lucy nearly came at the word alone. “You dirty whore… Slutty bitch!” He growled, continuing to fuck Lucy. His passion was becoming almost animalistic, and it was amazing. 

“I’m going to cum,” she confessed, panting as his cock pounded her pussy.

“Me too,” he panted, and he delivered one last slap to her ass. “Can I cum inside?” 

Lucy moaned loudly, shuddering, before she cried out an answer. “I’m on the pill! Go ahead, stud.” His fingers dug into her soft breast, squeezing it as he pushed his cock as far as it could go inside of her.

The two came together at the same time. Her pussy squeezed down on his cock as his semen shot into her, coating the moist walls of her womanhood. Sperm filled her, even filling her womb as she moaned loudly, trembling from the wonderful sensation.

They were both trembling as Romeo lazily played her breast, squeezing it. “I… I got one more in me,” he muttered. He kissed her skin, tasting her sweat, before he added, “I want to fuck you in the ass…”

That shocked Lucy. Her eyes widened as she thought that not even Natsu had fucked her ass yet. But if that was what Romeo wanted…

“Okay, but be gentle?” she asked, trying to hide her fear, but Romeo could still hear it. 

It didn’t take a genius to figure out that Lucy was an anal virgin. Natsu had never fucked that plump rear, and Romeo couldn’t help but feel pride that he would get to be the first.

Lucy pressed her hands against the wall as the dark-haired man took his cock by the base and pressed it against her asshole. He pushed it in slowly. Thankfully the dick was lubed up from her pussy and mouth. 

He let Lucy get used to it, and she trembled, biting her lower lip as she felt it stretch her out. She was trying to catch her breath, moaning as pain slowly turned to pleasure.

“F-faster,” she whispered, and Romeo was only too happy to do so, pulling his dick out, before thrusting forward back. 

Lucy had never felt this filled before. Cum dripped from her pussy as she mewled, tongue hanging out of her mouth as pleasure coursed through her body. She panted, trembling as his hand spanked her ass again, making her squeeze tighter around his shaft.

“Ahh! Y-you feel good, Romeo,” she praised, and she got another spank for her tight ass.

“You feel amazing, Lucy! You’re the best!” And he pulled on her hair, making her lean back so that their lips could meet. He kept playing with her breast as his tongue slipped into her mouth again, wrestling with her own.

His cock continued to plow Lucy’s ass, ramming into it again and again, making the blond moan loudly into his mouth. A trickle of saliva went down her chin as her eyes rolled into her skull. Her ass squeezed tighter around the shaft, stroking the sides of it as Romeo handled her. 

“Cum… cum inside,” she begged. “Please, I-I want your cum to fill my ass!” Romeo grinned, fucking her ass even fighter as Lucy howled in pleasure. 

Her pussy juices dripped to the ground as both of them felt the end coming. They came together one last time, and Lucy screamed as his seed shot into her ass, coating the walls of it like he had with her pussy.

The two stood there, panting, before Romeo slowly slid his dick out of her and fell back onto his seat. He was panting as semen dripped out of Lucy’s ass, and the beautiful blond sank down to her knees. 

Romeo was sure the woman was exhausted, but he watched her turn towards him and crawl. She walked on all fours, shaking her ass slightly, before wrapping her lips around his dick and cleaning his cock.

“You were pretty, mmh, bold back there,” she told him, between kisses and licks.

The young man let out a nervous chuckle. “Guess I just wanted to feel bigger than Natsu.”

Lucy giggled, before lifting her head up and pecking the young man’s lips. His eyes widened and his cheeks turned a bright red as she smiled at him. 

“I had fun… You know, if you stay a good boy, I might just give you the same present again next year… Or sooner if you’re extra good,” she teased with a wink.