Prompt: Lucy's Funtime with Friends Ch. 4 (Fairy Tail)

Summary: Lucy goes to see Natsu, hoping to invite him to a threesome with her and Flare, only to find a special guest is already with her boyfriend. She soon hears all about what her boyfriend's been doing behind her back... Includes: Cheating sex, Threesome

---

Lucy had a slight skip to her step as she walked towards Natsu and Happy’s home. She was excited to pop a question to her lover, and she hoped he would say yes. The question was simple. Did he want to have a threesome with her and Flare.

Honestly, she couldn’t imagine him saying no. She and Natsu didn’t have the chance to have sex with others yet together. Well, Gemini, but that didn’t really count, did it?

The blond felt a rush of excitement at the idea of riding Natsu’s cock while another woman kissed her lips or licked her breasts…

She arrived at the front door of her boyfriend’s house, but her hand froze before she could even touch it. She heard a strange, yet familiar sound coming from inside the house. Lucy blinked, listening closely as she heard a woman’s voice, but she couldn’t place it…

Curiosity took control of Lucy, and she quietly opened the door and slipped inside the house. She was quiet as could be, and silently thankful that her boyfriend never locked the door. What did he have to worry about regarding security?

Lucy kept low to the ground as she walked inside, and she moved closer to her boyfriend’s room as the sounds became even more familiar. Moaning, screaming, the usual stuff Lucy had been hearing these last few days… 

She peeked into Natsu’s bedroom, and she gasped at what she saw. She saw a woman with short, green hair being pounded into the ground as he hung over her. He slammed his cock into her wet pussy in a mating press right there in the middle of the room.

And who was that woman? None other than Brandish, the woman who accused Lucy’s mother of murdering her own mother. 

While the two had managed to find the truth and bury the hatchet, Lucy was still shocked to see Brandish in her boyfriend’s house. The buxom woman screamed in pleasure as Natsu pounded her, slamming into her again and again. Her pussy juices coated his cock as Brandish howled in pleasure. 

“I-I’m cumming!” 

“Me… too!” 

Lucy watched the two cum together, covering her mouth as she watched her boyfriend fire a thick load of cum right into Brandish’s cunt. She could see Brandish’s body twitching as she threw her head back, eyes rolled into her skull as her tongue licked the open air. Natsu buried his face against her skin, licking and kissing whatever skin he could get his mouth on…

Lucy wondered if this was their first time. Her face turned red as she licked her lips. Had Natsu been fucking Brandish on the side? For days? Weeks? Was she the only one?

Brandish’s face was nothing like the calm expression she usually had. Her mouth was wide, tongue out, and tears fell down her face as her fucked silly smile glows bright on her face. She looks like a slut, riding the waves of her climax as Natsu sniffed the air.

He turned his head, and his eyes caught the blond hiding just behind his door. He grinned, and he thrust his hips forward into Brandish, making her moan and quiver. “Hey. We’ve got a visitor, slut.”

Knowing that the jig was up, Lucy opened the door and walked forward. Her face was red as she pressed a hand against her chest, right between her breasts. Natsu seemed to read her mind as her eyes bounced between his naked body and Brandish’s.

He pulled out of the emerald-haired woman and sat back, sitting on a chair. “Hey, I’m allowed to have affairs to,” he chuckled. 

Lucy’s face continued to glow red as she remembered what Gray said about letting Natsu have affairs too. Lo and behold...

“Do you remember when I went on that week-long mission?” How could she forget. It was the same week she started sleeping around with so many different people… “Well, I started fucking Brandish during that mission. She’s been coming to me ever since, begging for my cock.”

As if to accent the face, Brandish let out a loud, sensual moan, cum trickling out of her pussy onto the floor. Lucy stared at her, watching the sweat on her skin glisten as she began to move beyond just twitching. She was getting up, Natsu’s seed dripping onto the ground as her eyes turned to Lucy.

Lucy was paralyzed, still trying to comprehend everything that she had seen and heard. Her lips parted, but nothing came out. Her words were caught in her throat as Brandish moved forward, hips swaying side to side as she placed her hands on Lucy’s cheeks. 

“W-wait-mmph!?”

Brandish pulled Lucy in for a kiss, and Lucy’s eyes widened as Brandish’s tongue plunged into her mouth, sliding along her teeth and smacking against Lucy’s tongue. The blond could taste her boyfriend’s cum off of the other woman’s mouth as Brandish’s tongue thrust back and forth inside her mouth…

She broke the kiss as soon as she had started it. Lucy leaned forward on instinct to continue the kiss, only for Brandish to laugh, holding Lucy back with a hand on her breast. Lucy was blushing as Brandish winked at her, leaving her to walk back over to Natsu and his hard cock.

Brandish opened her mouth and took the cock into her mouth, moaning at the taste as she began to lower her head down the thick shaft. She then lifted herself back up, sucking on the penis, before kissing the tip and going back down on the cock. Her head bobbed up and down, letting the tip of his cock press against the inside of her cheek.

She moaned, and Natsu grinned as the vibrations went up his cock. His eyes looked at Lucy as he grinned. “You gonna stand there all day or join us?”

Lucy sighed, her face hot and scarlet as she pulled at her clothes. She had questions about the affair Natsu was having, but she kept quiet for now.  She’d ask him later about who else he slept with, but for now she was going to have fun with her boyfriend…. And their plus one.

The gorgeous blond opened her mouth and began to suck on Natsu’s balls, making him moan in pleasure as her tongue smacked against his nuts. Brandish popped the cock out of her mouth, licking the tip, before kissing a line down to join Lucy in worshipping his balls.

The two women coated his cock and balls with kisses, soon trading places as Lucy kissed her way up to the tip of his penis. She took the cock into her mouth, moaning as she moved her head back and forth, letting it stretch her throat and slide deeper into her.

Natsu placed a hand on her head, fucking her face as Brandish sucked on the shaft, feeling it quivering against her lips. The young man moaned in pleasure as Lucy popped the dick out of her mouth, panting.

“How long were you two at it before I got here?”

“A couple of hours.” Lucy turned her head to look at Brandish, who spoke between kisses on the hard cock. She gave Lucy a knowing smile, winking at her. “Your boyfriend’s amazing, Lucy…”

Lucy blushed as Brandish moved her face close to Lucy’s, before moving her head down to take the cock into her mouth.

“H-hey!” Lucy frowned, clearly jealous as Brandish sucked Natsu’s dick. 

She pulled on Brandish’s body, and while normally Brandish was stronger than Lucy, she was also exhausted from her hours of fucking with Natsu’s. The taller woman was pulled off of the cock, and Lucy grinned as she wrapped her lips around her boyfriend’s cock, sucking on the bulbous head.

Natsu moaned, louder than he had with Brandish, and Lucy’s rival frowned as she listened to Lucy’s mouth. The blond knew just where to attack to make Natsu moan, licking all over his cock and sucking the tip. Her hand stroked his shaft, moving up and down as Brandish grabbed Lucy by her tits. 

The blond’s eyes widened as Brandish’s fingers pressed against her nipples, before she pulled Lucy right off of the cock, shoving her aside. Lucy fell onto her side, unharmed, but annoyed as Brandish took her place, wrapping her plump lips around the dragon’s beastly member.

Lucy shook her head, but inside, she couldn’t help but think how cute it was. Brandish was addicted to Natsu’s cock, and Lucy let her have her fun as she placed her hands on Brandish’s body, groping her tits as the other woman sucked his cock.

“Here. Let me help you,” Lucy smiled, pushing her forward so that Brandish’s tits were pressed against Natsu’s dick. Brandish then watched as Lucy moved towards her side, and realizing what she was doing, the two gorgeous women wrapped their tits around Natsu’s cock, stroking his dick up and down with their tits.

The two gave Natsu a double boobjob, and Natsu moaned in pleasure as their soft tits stroked the sides of his dick. He felt their soft flesh envelop him, covering his penis in their warm titties. 

Both ladies stuck out their tongues, licking the tip of Natsu’s cock. Their tongues dragged along the bulbous head, licking one another. Both girls shared a glance, before they proceeded to kiss one another before Natsu, letting the young man admire them kiss right before his eyes. Their tongues wrestled, smacking and pressing against one another as they moaned into each other’s lips. 

“Cum for us, baby,” Lucy moaned, breaking the kiss as Brandish squeezed her tits around Natsu’s rack. 

“Cum all over us, Master!” she begged, and Natsu moaned loudly as his cock erupted, firing semen onto their faces. 

Both girls were given a facial of cum, and they moaned in pleasure together as they took one glance at the other. Without any warning, the two began to lick each other, moaning as their lips kissed the other’s skin. Lucy licked a glob of semen off of Brandish’s cheeks as the other woman licked Lucy’s lower lip of cum.

“Brandish had her fun,” Lucy panted, licking her glistening lips. “Now I want to ride you.”

Natsu was happy to agree as Lucy climbed onto him, bringing her pussy down on his cock as she moaned in pleasure. Brandish watched for a moment, her eyes following Lucy bouncing up and down on Natsu’s cock. Lucy’s eyes jiggled as Brandish moved around them, getting behind Natsu and wrapping her arms around him.

She stroked his naked chest as Lucy and Brandish’s eyes met. The green-haired woman smirked, before she turned Natsu’s head and kissed his lips. Her lips were tender and soft, and he closed his eyes as his tongue pushed into her mouth.

Lucy pouted as she watched the two kiss, only to moan as Natsu’s cock trembled inside of her. She tried to focus on that, rising and falling, letting her large breasts clap against her chest as she rode her boyfriend. She picked up speed, feeling the dick stretch and fill her pussy as she watched Brandish break the kiss.

“Your girlfriend looks like a real slut,” Brandish commented, and Lucy grinned as she replied.

“Y-yeah. I’m his slut. No matter how many people I sleep with, I’m his.”

Brandish giggled at the comment, before she suddenly leaned forward. Lucy met her in the middle. While her pussy was being stuffed full of Natsu’s flesh, the two women kissed once more, tongues wrestling for dominance as Brandish even groped one of Lucy’s large breasts.

The two continued to kiss as pleasure built up inside of Lucy. She broke the kiss and quivered, feeling the cock throbbing inside of her.

“Ahh! I-I’m gonna cum!” That made Natsu grin, and he proceeded to grab Lucy’s hips and fuck her at his speed. Her eyes widened and she screamed in pleasure as she bounced on his cock faster and faster. Her eyes rolled into her skull as she leaned her head back, quivering as the cock pistoned in and out of her. 

“Cum for me, baby,” he growled, matching the animalistic rate he was fucking her. 

She came on his cock, and her pussy tightened and squeezed his shaft. He groaned, shaking as Lucy expected his speed to cover her insides. Her pussy juices were covering him, no doubt there. 

Lucy’s body quivered, but when nothing happened, the blond bounced and lifted herself up off of him. She was impressed by his self control, but she so badly wanted to be fucked by him…

“Why don’t you lay down, Brandish?” Lucy suggested, and the other woman nodded. Once she was on her back, Lucy got on top of her, and the two sexy sluts rubbed their huge breasts against the other, moaning quietly in heavenly bliss.

Natsu got behind them, and he took his cock by the base, rubbing the head against Lucy’s pussy, before doing the same for Brandish. Both women moaned, shaking as their nipples poked into each other and Natsu’s dick teased their bodies. 

He rubbed his cock between their clits, lubing his shaft with more of their juices. Lucy kissed Brandish, moaning into the other woman’s mouth as Natsu continued to tease them. They rubbed their equally perfect, round breasts against the other. He could hear the wet smack of their tongues inside each other’s mouths as he stared at them.

The two broke apart, saliva linking each other’s mouths as they moaned together. Lucy licked up the lines of saliva as she smacked her tits against Brandish’s, smacking the other woman’s around.

“Baby,” Lucy moaned. “S-stop teasing us! F-fuck me, fuck her, just fuck one of us!” she shouted. 

“Y-yeah, Master! Don’t you want to feel our tight pussies around your cock…?” Brandish panted.

Natsu didn’t say anything, only grinning ear to ear as he continued to thrust between the girls. His cock brushed against their clits, and they both loudly moaned as the small, wet nubs dragged along his dick. The two women were shaking, hearts racing as their bodies burned hot with desire. 

Natsu made the two girls cum without even really fucking them. He just kept moving his cock back and forth, and soon the two were cumming from the build up of pleasure. He could feel their juices splattering on his cock, coating it as he dragged his member along her pussy walls...

The pink-haired man had a will of iron considering he had yet to cum. He was shaking as he placed his hands on Brandish’s ass, digging his fingers into her cheeks as he thrusted forward. The entire length of the cock vanished inside of Lucy as she cried out in blissful pleasure..

Brandish watched with jealousy as Natsu fucked his girlfriend. It only took a few thrusts for Natsu to cum, and Brandish got a front row seat to Lucy’s fucked silly smile. Lucy cried out in ecstasy, trembling as semen coated the walls of her womanhood.

“Can I have some cum too…?” Brandish pouted. 

Natsu delivered a fast smack to the green-haired girl’s ass, and she moaned loudly. Natsu pulled out of Lucy, not even done cumming yet. His semen shot onto Lucy’s cunt, before he slammed his penis into Brandish’s pussy, fucking her just like he had Lucy.

Lucy giggled, watching Brandish moan and bounce slightly everytime Natsu slammed into her. The sound of her pussy being fucked filled the air as the blond whispered into Brandish’s ear.

“If it's Natsu’s cum you want, you can have what’s inside my pussy.”

“W-what?” Natsu heard Lucy, and he picked Brandish up. The three adjusted so that Brandish was on her back, and Lucy was kneeling over her.

Lucy then pressed her pussy against the other woman’s face, and she moaned against her pussy lips as cum trickled onto her face. Brandish licked the cum oozing out of the other woman’s pussy, lost to a fog of lust just like the two lovers. 

Brandish dragged her tongue along Lucy’s pussy, before she began to suck the cum right out of her. 

Natsu kept thrusting into Brandish, moving at a slower rate to better torture the gorgeous woman. He looked at Lucy and smiled, speaking to her as if it was the most natural thing in the world. 

“So, why’d you come here in the first place?”

“I-I-ahh!” Lucy shuddered, shocked at just how good Brandish was with her tongue and lips. She moaned loudly as the other woman’s lips kissed her pussy, sucking on it gently. “I-I came t-to ask you-ahh, a-about a-a threesome with Fla-aaah, fuck!”

“With Flare?” Natsu laughed at the statement. “I’m down for a threesome anytime, any day.” He leaned forward and nuzzled his nose against hers. The gesture was oddly innocent and romantic as she was fucked on Brandish’s tongue. “Weirdo,” he teased.”

“I-I’m your weirdo.” She kissed him, and Natsu moaned as he came inside of Brandish, filling her pussy with another load of cum. The woman fell to exhaustion afterwards, and both Lucy and Natsu could tell she was out of the fight for now.

They broke apart, and Lucy grinned. “Can you go one more round?”

“Heh. Don’t underestimate a dragon slayer’s stamina!” 

“Then come fuck my ass…”

Lucy pulled away and got near a wall, leaning forward to push her round ass out towards him. Natsu licked his lips and came closer to her, bringing his hand down to smack her ass. He watched it ripple and jiggle as Lucy moaned.

“So, is Flare any good?” 

Lucy nodded her head as she panted. “She’s so, so good with a goddess of a body.”

“Well, I can’t wait to taste her, but first...” Natsu thrusted into Lucy, slipping his whole cock into her ass as she screamed in pleasure.

Natsu thrusted faster and harder, and Lucy cried out in pleasure, screaming his name as her face nearly smacked against the wall. She tried to remain firm, but his constant barrage of thrusts was making her ass jiggle and her legs wobble. 

“Natsu! Ahh! Natsu!” 

Lucy was already sensitive from everything that had happened recently. Her body was shaking from the waves of pleasure coursing through her. And now a cock was pistoning in and out of her asshole, filling her butt, pounding her insides.

The tip of his cock smacked against her insides, and she screamed his name as she nearly came from the ass fucking. Her ass tightened around his cock, squeezing his member as she squeezed her eyes shut. She howled with pleasure as his cock throbbed inside of her, rubbing against her insides…

“I-I’m so close, Natsu…” 

He grinned, lifting her leg and fucking her sideways. Her leg rubbed against his shoulder as he continued to pound her butt, sending jolts of pleasure through her body. He grabbed her arm and pulled on her, mashing their lips together as his cock throbbed inside of her. 

She came on his cock, and her muscles spasmed as her mind nearly snapped from the pleasure. Her ass wrapped tightly around his shaft, squeezing his cock as Lucy moaned into his mouth. 

He broke the kiss, licking her saliva up as she panted and mewled in his hands. “I’m going to cum now, slut…”

“I-inside me.” She brought her hand to her face tracing her lower lip with a smile. “Please?”

He grinned, dropping her gently onto the ground as he took his dick out of her. She fell onto her knees and opened her mouth, taking his cock without hesitation. She sucked on it, bobbing her head back and forth, before letting it pop out of her mouth.

“List all the women you’ve been fucking,” she panted. 

“Lisanna , Jenny , Kinana , Levy...” he answered, each name sending a shiver of pleasure through her body. Her pussy tingled as her lips tightened around Natsu’s thick erection.  

“And Juvia.” With the cock still plunged into her mouth, Lucy’s eyes widened. 

“Don’t tell Gray,” Natsu laughed, and Lucy joined him as her hand brought him to orgasm. Cum splattered onto her face as Lucy basked in the warm shower of jizz. 

She loved her boyfriend, and it really seemed they were meant for each other…

---

Later that night, Brandish returned home, leaving the two alone. They fucked for hours, but now they were laying outside the house. They cuddled by the lake behind his home, enjoying the moon’s reflection on the water.

It was a beautiful sight, and Lucy couldn’t help but think about how perfect the contrast was compared to what she saw with Flare. 

All they wore was their underwear as Lucy rested her head on his shoulder. “Is… is our relationship weird? I mean, us wanting to keep on sleeping with people…”

“Yeah, it’s weird,” he shrugged, and Lucy cringed at how blunt he was. “But is it fun?”

Lucy couldn’t lie to her boyfriend about that... “Well, yeah, but-”

“Then fuck it. It’s fine by me. If we’re messed up, then we’re messed up. That doesn’t change who we are. No one can tell us who we are.” He wrapped an arm around Lucy, squeezing her in a hug as he grinned. “This is our choice, no one else’s.”

Lucy felt her cheeks turn red and her heart skip a beat. She beamed at her boyfriend, nuzzling his body. “You’re crazy.”

“Yeah, well, we both are.” He chuckled, and Lucy laughed with him as the moon shined bright over them, like a beacon of their love...