Prompt: Seeking Payback (Fairy Tail)

Summary: Having been bullied and attacked by Aquarius one too many times, Lucy decides to get back at her for everything she's done. How? By sleeping with Scorpio and proving to him who the better woman is. Includes: NTR and Anal

---

Lucy groaned as she stumbled back into her house. She rubbed her head, fighting back a yawn as she stumbled inside of her home. She dragged herself into the humble abode, before kicking the door shut behind her. 

She blew some hair out of her face as she fell onto her bed, sighing. 

Normally, after a mission’s successful end, she wouldn’t be so… bummed out, but today was just the final straw for a very tired, very overworked animal. 

Lucy had summoned Aquarius to help them defeat a violent and fiery criminal, and she attacked as Lucy had asked… She just got Lucy swept up in the wave of water too. After that, Lucy scolded and yelled at Aquarius, but the spirit just shrugged it off and gave that same rude, condescending tone she always had…

The blond would have thought that after all this time, things might get better between the two, but even after they both had boyfriends, Aquarius treated her the same as ever. She would brag and brag that Scorpio was better than Natsu, that he knew how to love a woman, that he was so much better than Natsu.

Aquarius nagged, and nagged, and nagged Lucy until the blonde was ready to pull her hair out. It was infuriating.

Lucy laid on her bed, scowling as she thought of all the abuse Aquarius had thrown her way. All the waves, all the floods, and all the insults… Lucy had tried being the bigger woman, tried playing nice, but Aquarius just wouldn’t have it.

Fine. Lucy was ready to play dirty then. Aquarius could brag about who had the better boyfriend all she wanted. Lucy was about to prove who the better girlfriend was.

Tonight she was going to get payback. 

Lucy sat up on her bed and took out a single golden key. She held it out and she summoned Scorpio to her room, watching as he appeared in a bright flash of light. He grinned at her, a proud smile on his face as he tilted his head.

“Hey, Lucy. What do you need?” He flashed his usual hand gesture, symbolizing a scorpion’s pincher as he looked around the room. “Doesn’t look like you're in the middle of a fight.”

“No, I actually need you for something else.” Lucy took a deep breath, before she began to explain to Scorpio her feelings. “I’m tired of Aquarius’ smug comments. I want payback against her.”

“Hey, look…” Scorpio was shockingly nicer than his girlfriend. Lucy never understood how they could date as he sat on her bed, being careful not to put the full weight of his tail on the bed. “I’m real sorry about Aquarius’ behavior lately. It’s not right. If you want some help, I can see what I can do.”

Lucy beamed at that. She placed a hand on his chest, leaning closer as Scorpio blinked. He blushed slightly as her hand stroked his muscular, built arm. He raised his brow as she leaned in a little closer, pressing her breast against his arm.

“Well, since Aquarius likes to brag so much about her sex appearl and how you love her skills in the bedroom…”

“Wait, she tells you about that?” he blinked, a faint blush on his dark, tanned skin. Lucy had to admit, he looked pretty cute while blushing.

“She does. In great detail,” Lucy huffed. “Anyways, I wanted to show you my own skills so you can compare us.”

“Y-your skills?” he repeated, his usual confidence fading as he began to put together just what Lucy was about to ask of him. “It’s your choice, obviously, but if you want to have some fun and settle the question, well… I’m going to need you to get naked,” she giggled, pulling on the buttons on her shirt, exposing her large breasts to the air.

Scorpio’s eyes widened and he gulped as he glanced down, staring at her jiggling, bouncing breasts. She moved her body up and down, helping keep his eyes there as a small battle was fought in his mind. 

He really didn’t want to betray his girlfriend, but… but Lucy was so smoking hot. She was a bombshell, a total ten out of ten. Besides, Lucy was his Master, and he could disobey her, could he? 

Scorpio’s battle didn’t last long. He’d take whatever hell Aquarius would throw at him if it meant he got to be with Lucy for just one night. He pulled at his own clothes, watching as Lucy stood up and began to strip for him.

She swayed her hips side to side as she slid her skirt down her long, slender legs. They fell to the ground as she giggled, letting him look at her pink underwear. She posed for a moment, even turning around so he could better check out her ass.

“Like what you see?” Scorpio nodded his head as Lucy licked her lips, noticing the tent he was sporting. 

Lucy finished taking off her clothes as Scorpio tossed his own clothes off. They were soon naked, and Scorpio was practically drooling as he looked Lucy over. Her large breasts, her round ass, her small waist, and her wide hips… Fuck, everything about her was hot. She was gorgeous, and Lucy posed for him.

She let him eat up the sight of her as she looked at his muscular body, but best of all, that hard, throbbing dick he was packing.

“Now, this’ll be between us, right? I just want to prove to you who is better.”

“Y-yeah! Let’s go!” he grinned, nodding his head rapidly as Lucy strutted closer to him.

She was glad Natsu was off on a camping trip with Happy. She didn’t want him to accidentally stumble inside her home. 

The gorgeous woman sank to her knees and wrapped her lips around the cock, moaning as she felt her lips drag along the veiny, dark shaft. She pressed her tongue along the bottom of his dick, sliding back and forth as she began to take more and more of the dick.

She slurped on it, loudly, letting the sound of her sucking his dick fill the room as he moaned. He placed a hand on her head, panting as her tongue slid along the shaft, licking one side, before licking at the other.

Her tongue moved all over the thick shaft, and she listened to the moans she was earning from the man as his hand combed through her soft, golden locks.

“Oh, fuck… You’re really good at that. Fuck, use your t-tongue, right-mmmph!” 

Lucy moved her head lower down the shaft, feeling the cock fill her throat, stretching the tight hole out. She gagged, choking on the member, and Scorpio showed a glint of concern. 

“Y-you okay?”

She nodded her head with the dick still in her mouth, before she pushed forward. Scorpio watched with wide, shocked eyes as she took his member down inch by inch. Her throat quivered as she stuffed her mouth full of his cock until her nose was buried against his crotch. 

“Oh, fuck… Aquarius n-never-fuck, she never took my dick that quickl-eee...Ahh, fuck, Lucy. Your mouth is so tight.

Lucy sucked on the cock, letting her tongue coat the penis in her saliva, before she slid back. Scorpio moaned loudly, shuddering as she nearly let the dick pop out of her mouth. She took long, deep breaths through her nose, before she took her tits and wrapped them around the thick dick.

“Oh, hell yes,” he moaned, moving his hips slightly, pushing his dick deeper into her mouth and letting the sides of it rub against her large, full tits.

Lucy was kind enough to do the work for him, wrapping her tits around his shaft and moving herself up and down. Her large breasts enveloped the cock, stroking the sides of his dick with their warm, soft flesh. She made sure to squeeze her tits around the shaft, moaning around his cock as the penis throbbed between her lips.

The blonde kept this up for a couple of minutes, letting Scorpio lose himself to the pleasurable sensation. Her tongue drew circles around the tip of his dick, before popping off of it, and licking her lips.

“Who has the better tits, Scorpio?” Of course, she already knew the answer to that particular question, she wanted to hear it from his lips. 

He gave her exactly what she wanted. “You… You do,” he panted as her tits slapped against his veiny member. “You’ve got such amazing fucking tits,” he moaned. “Your breasts are so much bigger. Aquarius always complained about how you had a bigger rack than her… But fuck, I didn’t think you’d be even better at her at sucking me off.”

Hearing that Lucy really was better than the arrogant spirit brought a smile to her lips. She licked her lips, tasting his precum as she kissed the tip of his dick. She sucked on it with her plump, pillowy lips, before smacking her tongue against it.

“You suck my dick way better than her…” The praise sent a tremble down her spine, and her pussy quivered slightly as she felt herself grow more and more wet. 

She returned to sucking his dick, giving it her all as her large breasts rubbed against his thick member. She felt the cock push down her throat again, battering the inside of her neck as it sank down into her. Her face did its best to sink between her tits as she sucked on the cock, feeling globs of his precum coat the inside of her throat, even sliding down to fall into her stomach.

Lucy couldn’t help but admire the taste. Her pussy quivered as a drop of her arousal hit the floor, and she felt the member throbbing in her throat. 

“Oh, fuck. I-I’m gonna cum,” he moaned, and Lucy lifted her head. She didn’t let the dick pop out of her mouth, no. She just went back until only her lips were wrapped around the head of his dick… before she plunged back down.

She took the entire length of his cock inside of her mouth with one single push. His cock couldn’t take it. He came in her throat, shooting his cum deep into her stomach as she moaned. Tears fell down her face, even as her jaw ached. 

It hurt, but Lucy was determined to prove her superiority of Scorpio’s semen shot into her belly. She trembled, more of her pussy juices falling to the ground as her hands jiggled slightly, nearly rubbing against his balls.

The two panted, before looking at one another. She pulled her head off of his dick, gasping for air as he patted the bed. They both grinned as Lucy got onto the bed and he leaned back, laying on his back as she fell onto his dick, letting it fill her pussy.

Lucy bounced on top of him, riding his dick as she felt his penis fill her pussy. She moaned loudly, panting as she gave herself a moment to adjust to the monster. She wasn’t sure earlier, but now she knew. His dick was bigger than Natsu’s…

The beautiful blonde slowly lifted her body up, before falling back down onto his dick. She moaned, feeling it rub against the wet walls of her maidenhood as she took things slow. Her pace didn’t satisfy Scorpio, though, and he grinned as he gave it to her a bit rougher than Aquarius could take it.

“Ah!” Lucy gasped, suddenly pulled down. The two rolled on the bed, and before Lucy knew what was happening, she was on her back with Scorpio on top of her and his dick sinking deeper into her pussy. She cried out again, but this time it was the pleasure as she felt the penis push into her, and then back out.

“Oh, fuck…”

“Like that? I’m rougher with you than I am with Aquarius. Course, you can take it, right?” he asked, and Lucy nodded her head as she begged him.

“Y-yes! I’m better! P-please! Pound my pussy! You’re so big! D-do a mating press on me!” she begged, tears falling down her face as her pussy juices stained the bed below them. Scorpio grinned, wondering if Lucy was somehow reading his mind.

She wanted exactly what he had always wanted to give to his girlfriend, but Aquarius was never up for it. She wasn’t capable of taking a pounding at Scorpio’s best, but it looked like their owner was. 

Scorpio felt his cock throbbing inside of Lucy as he did as she asked, really fucking her into the bed, making it groan as her body was slammed into it again and again. The springs creaked with every thrust as Lucy’s eyes nearly rolled into her skull. She wrapped her arms around him, squeezing him as she pounded her into the bed. 

The two just went at it, gasping and moaning as their sweaty bodies clung to one another. Lucy’s tight pussy wrapped tightly around his member, embracing it as he felt himself getting closer and closer to an orgasm. He moved faster, rubbing along the inner walls of her pussy, kissing the entrance of her womb with the tip of his dick.

Lucy suddenly gasped, before she dug her nails into him as she cried out. “I-I’m cumming! C-can I cum inside?” he asked, only for her to shake her head.

“P-please, cum on the outside?” she panted, and he was kind enough to agree as they both felt it.

They came at the same time as he pulled out, shooting cum all over the outside of her pussy. Lucy’s arms and legs wrapped tight around him as they panted, gently nuzzling one another.

Eventually the two pulled away, just a bit to look into each other’s eyes. “I got one last shot in me,” he admitted. “Mind if I get a feel for that ass?”

Lucy grinned, before licking her lips. “Go ahead.” The beautiful blond got up and laid on all four as he got behind her, sitting on his knees. He took his dick by the base and pressed it against her ass, and she moaned as his slick, wet penis began to enter her asshole.

The gorgeous woman shuddered, almost losing strength in her arms as more and more his cock entered her. It wasn’t hard. His dick was lubed up with her pussy juices and the leftover cum from when he was banging her cunt. 

“Spank me! Please, spank me!” she pleaded and he was happy to do just that, smacking her ass and slowly painting it red.

“Fuck, your ass is so much tighter than Aquarius!”

Lucy beamed at that, shaking her ass side to side as he fucked it. “It’s better than hers, isn’t it? Way bigger and softer!”

“You’re god damn right it is!”

He leaned down, kissing her lips, and pushing his tongue into her mouth. She moaned as she felt the tongue licking hers, coiling around her tongue and wrestling hers down as tears fell down her face. Her ass clenched tighter around his dick, squeezing it as their lips smacked against one another.

It didn’t take long for them both to climax, feeling the rush of pleasure and ecstasy going through them as they came together. Scorpio pumped her full of his seed, shooting it into her asshole, coating her insides with it as Lucy mewled in pleasure. 

She felt his sperm cling to the inside of her ass and fill her belly to the point where her stomach felt overfilled with his seed. She panted, shaking as her arms finally gave out and her face fell onto the bed. 

She came, staining the bed with her juices as his semen dripped out of her asshole and onto the bed’s soft sheets. He pulled out of her, letting cum spill out from her ass as he fell onto the bed. He sighed, rubbing his head as Lucy panted beside him.

The two looked at one another, both drenched in sweat. Scorpio grinned as he watched her shapely body shimmer from the layer of sweat on her. She looked so damn sexy, and his dick was already hardening again.

Lucy grinned, licking her lips as she watched the dick hardening between his legs. She knew that she had proven who was better. Payback was sweet...